Lit Chat’s Best Books of 2023: Round Two

Housekeeping note: all book links go to my Bookshop storefront, where each purchase supports independent bookstores (and this newsletter, because I get a small percentage of each sale).


Hi friends,

Welcome back for another round of my highly subjective Best Books of 2023 bracket! Today, we have six titles facing off for the honor of making it to the top three, which makes this the semifinals already! Here’s where we stand so far:

Best Books of 2023 bracket image

Also, a quick reminder that you can get this post directly to your inbox if you subscribe to my Substack!

All right, it’s a gloomy day in Brooklyn; let’s talk about some books.


ROUND TWO:

Book cover images for Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin and Homie by Danez Smith

Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin vs. Homie by Danez Smith

I so wish I didn’t have to put these two head to head because they are truly in leagues of their own, but so it goes. When I think of comparing these two books, I think of scope: Homie, though completely wonderful, simply feels small in comparison to the sprawling saga that is Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow. What I love about Homie is how it does so much emotionally with such a small space, as a testament to all the people and places the poet loves, but we don’t necessarily get to know those people as closely as we do when we follow their lives for decades like we do in Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow. At their core, both books are centered around friendship, which is why this feels slightly unfair because a novel is a completely different vehicle for exploring the nuances of that friendship and, in this case, the worlds that are created as a result. While I loved feeling like a witness to Danez Smith’s highly personal world, I felt fully inside not only Sam and Sadie’s real lives, but also each of the worlds they created in their games. This expansiveness is why I’m moving Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow forward, though it’s with a heavy heart that I leave Homie behind.

Book cover images for Happy Place by Emily Henry and Yellowface by R.F. Kuang

Happy Place by Emily Henry vs. Yellowface by R.F. Kuang

Something I’ve learned about myself and my media consumption habits lately is that fundamentally, I am not a hater but a liker. I like to enjoy things, and I am fairly easily pleased! Unless I am specifically approaching something with skepticism, I’m more than happy to turn the critical thinking part of my brain off for the sake of entertainment. Some books are better suited for this than others—in my initial read of Happy Place, I was perfectly happy to be along for the ride. I love stories that feature big friend groups, particularly ones in the same phase of life as me, so I was content to overlook the fact that the secondary characters often fell a little flat. I also love rooting for a good romance, especially when we’re more concerned with the characters’ chemistry than the fact that it’s completely insane to (spoiler) abandon a neurosurgery degree that you’re hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt for to become a…potter? Details, details! Suspend disbelief for love! I still had a great time with Happy Place, but as many of my more critical friends were quick to point out, there are definitely some holes.

Yellowface, on the other hand, is meant to be insane. Yellowface is written from the perspective of a hater and a grasper and an all-around kind of terrible person, and there’s something so delicious about being inside her head and watching from behind your fingers as she continues to make shocking decisions. As a commentary on race and privilege in the publishing industry, Yellowface ultimately also has more to say in general than an unconcerned-with-reality rom-com. I have more I want to say about Yellowface still, which is why I’m officially moving it forward to the finals.

Book cover images for Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel and Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel vs. Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

This one is TOUGH. The hard thing about this bracket is that a book like Sea of Tranquility would have easily beat out so many others on this list, but against Never Let Me Go it’s a lot less of a wash. These two are similar in genre, and both stayed on my mind for a long time after reading, though for different reasons. As a time-travel story, I spent days puzzling through the events of Sea of Tranquility and how each action seemed perfectly placed to affect not just the story, but also our understanding of time, space, and free will. It presented a fascinating intellectual question that, in its narrative execution, could also be appreciated as a masterful work of literature. It’s still one of my favorite books of the year, but its impact isn’t quite on the scale of Never Let Me Go.

The way that Never Let Me Go continues to take up space in my brain can only be described as a haunting. For a sci-fi/speculative fiction novel, it’s eerie how easily the reader finds themselves settling into daily life at Hailsham, how normalized and almost comfortable it is as a setting in which we’re happy to ignore the many, many red flags about the world beyond. And though a world in which (spoilers!!!) clone children are raised and groomed for the sole purpose of donating their organs does still feel far-fetched (for now), their treatment by society is all too familiar: othered, subhuman, and ultimately disposable. One of the most terrifying parts is realizing how easily we might agree with this thinking had we not spent the whole book watching these characters grow up, and yet the central question of whether or not the children have a soul is still not one I feel fully prepared to answer by the end of the book. It’s a question I’m not sure I’ll ever have a definitive answer for, but one I know I’ll be pondering for a very long time.


There you have it, my top three finalists! Come back tomorrow to see how the final three rank and check out a brief list of honorable mentions for books that I loved in 2023 but which didn’t make the bracket.

Thanks for reading, chat more soon!
❤ Catherine

Lit Chat’s Best Books of 2023: Round 1

Housekeeping note: all book links go to my Bookshop storefront, where each purchase supports independent bookstores (and this newsletter, because I get a small percentage of each sale).


Hi friends,

Happy New Year! Bet you thought you were done with end-of-year recaps in your inbox, huh? Lucky for you, the new year has done nothing to cure my pathological procrastination, so here we are a week later! Below is the start to my Best Books of 2023 bracket, courtesy of this graphic I found on Pinterest (thanks, @diariesofabibliophile, whoever you are!) and my very rudimentary Canva skills:

Bracket of book cover images for each calendar month of 2023.

In terms of rating criteria, we’re mostly going for vibes here: how I felt while reading, what’s stuck with me after I’ve finished, and overall impact (on me as a person, my tastes, my interests, my emotions, etc.). You may disagree—in fact, I hope you do and I hope you tell me about it! I love hearing from friends who have had different reading experiences than me.

This year was a particularly strong reading year, and some of my favorites didn’t even make this list by nature of coming in second to another rockstar book that month. I’d encourage you to check out the Lit Chat archives or poke around on my Bookshop storefront for other reading inspiration! I also love nothing more than giving a personal recommendation, so feel free to reach out if you’re in the mood for something specific but don’t know what that is yet.

Without further ado, let’s begin!


ROUND ONE:

Book cover images for The Sentence by Louise Erdrich and Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin

The Sentence by Louise Erdrich vs. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin

I’m upset about this already because it feels unfair to drop one of these phenomenal books so early. The Sentence was the first book I read in 2023 and set the bar high for its unique characters, sense of community, and portrayal of resilience in the face of so many personal and political upheavals (I was wrong last month when I said Tom Lake was my first Covid book; it was The Sentence!). The Sentence left me energized and inspired for my reading year ahead, whereas Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow was so emotionally all-encompassing that it left me with one of the worst book hangovers I’ve had in a long time. To have that happen so early in the year was daunting, to say the least. Ultimately, this is why Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow is going to move forward this round, although it pains me to say goodbye to The Sentence so early in the game.

Book cover images for Homie by Danez Smith and Fruiting Bodies by Kathryn Harlan

Homie by Danez Smith vs. Fruiting Bodies by Kathryn Harlan

Another tough but very different match-up! Listening to Danez Smith narrate the audiobook for Homie was one of the highlights of my winter, eclipsed only by getting to see Danez perform live at the New York City Poetry Festival on Governors Island this summer. Likewise, Kathryn Harlan’s collection of eerily enchanting, female-centric short stories has also lingered with me this year, and I recently recommended it to a friend just last month. While Fruiting Bodies renewed my interest in short fiction and magical realism, there’s just something about listening to poems like my president, for Andrew, and waiting for you to die so i can be myself read aloud by the poet, feeling the raw emotion, joy, and vulnerability that exists in these exultations of friendship and community that feels timeless and transcendent. Homie wins this round!

Book cover images for The Hidden Oracle by Rick Riordan and Happy Place by Emily Henry

The Hidden Oracle by Rick Riordan vs. Happy Place by Emily Henry

This might be the silliest match-up of them all, but honestly, it’s still a real contest. The Hidden Oracle was top-notch mythological fun, and with the new Percy Jackson adaptation now streaming, I’m even more favorably inclined to move it along than I might have been a month ago. But to be fair, I forgot I even read this one, whereas I’ve had so many conversations with friends about Happy Place since reading that it’s stayed all too present in my mind. It’s one that I’ve found surprisingly controversial, and though I have plenty more thoughts, I’ll save them for the next round. Happy Place moves forward on the merit of being a thoroughly enjoyable read that is only slightly more relevant to my life as a late twenty-something than the book about fallen gods turned awkward teenagers. (Note to self: finish listening to the Trials of Apollo books in 2024.)

Book cover images for Les annees by Annie Ernaux and Yellowface by R.F. Kuang

Les Années (The Years) by Annie Ernaux vs. Yellowface by R.F. Kuang

You may remember that I didn’t actually finish a single book in July because of moving apartments and traveling, but I’m putting Annie Ernaux forward as the book I spent all of July reading when I had the time. While I spent almost a whole month trying to get through this one in the original French, I flew through Yellowface and its scandalously delightful satire of the publishing industry in a matter of days. I know Les Années is brilliant and I will return to it in English someday, but man, it made my brain so tired. Yellowface moves on to the next round!

Book cover images for Talking at Night by Claire Daverley and Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel

Talking at Night by Claire Daverley vs. Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel

This one is so hard!!! I love love loved Talking at Night, which had me smiling and crying and yearning my little heart out during my last international flight of the year. On the other hand, I read almost all of Sea of Tranquility in one sitting on my couch and thought about it for weeks after. Hell, I’m still thinking about it. Sea of Tranquility has buried itself in my brain in a way that was completely unexpected, and which has piqued my curiosity in terms of exploring other kinds of soft sci-fi. For this reason, I think it does ultimately beat out Talking at Night, but I will keep recommending that one to all my Sally Rooney girlies who love a slow-burn, long-game relationship story.

Book cover images for Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and An Echo in the Bone by Diana Gabaldon

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro vs. An Echo in the Bone by Diana Gabaldon

Finally, an easy one! There’s no contest here. I love the Outlander books, and diving into this one was a thoroughly enjoyable way to spend my December, but in terms of literary prowess and lasting impact, I have a feeling Never Let Me Go is going to go a long way in this bracket. While I will say this was one of the least stressful and most satisfying Outlander books in terms of character reunions, new relationships, and surprisingly positive outcomes to ill-fated mishaps, there is still simply no reason for these books to be as long as they are. I’ll keep reading them (and watching the show now that I’m caught up), but HOW does this woman get away with cranking out doorstopper after doorstopper!? That’s beside the point. Never Let Me Go wins, obviously.


And that’s a wrap on Round One! Come back tomorrow for Round Two as we narrow it down from the six semifinalists to the top three!

See you there,
❤ Catherine

Voices in Our Heads — March in Review

Get in, reader, we’re going shopping.

Pyramid of book covers with homie by danez smith on top; dyscalculia by camonghne felix and happy all the time by laurie colwin on the second row; poem's to eat by takuboku, american estrangement by said sayrafiezadeh, and people we meet on vacation by emily henry in the third row; we had to remove this post by hanna bervoets, the netflix poster for shadow and bone, a modern mephistopheles by louisa may alcott, and the movie poster for a quiet girl on the bottom row

Hey friends,

This newsletter is a little late in coming for two reasons: one, because I make the rules and I’ve been traveling, and two: I’ve been working on incorporating something new into these newsletters that I’m really excited to share!

First, I want to say how much I love it when one of you tells me you bought a book that I recommended here. It makes me feel so good inside! I love that you’re reading and supporting authors with me! The one thing I don’t love supporting is Amazon, because IMO, independent bookstores are infinitely more worth giving your money to than Schmeff Schmezos.

So starting this month, all of the books I talk about in this newsletter (and all the previous ones!) will be linked to my Bookshop storefront, where you can buy the book directly from a local bookstore of your choosing! Also, as an affiliate, I receive 10% of each sale, which you can think of as a little recommendation tip jar. I’ll never make this newsletter paid, so if you want to support me, consider buying a book! Then you have my undying gratitude plus a book, which is a pretty sweet deal.

Okay, that took up all my intro space. How have you been? Have you been good? I’ve been good. March was good to me and good for the books, so let’s get into it.


Honorable Mention:

We Had to Remove This Post — Hanna Bervoets

Translated from the Dutch, this book fits right into the genre of “mentally ill girls decidedly not thriving in absurd situations” novels that I somehow always seem to be reading. The narrator works for an unnamed social media company as a content moderator, tasked with the truly horrendous job of reviewing flagged content and deciding what gets to stay up. It’s as sinister as you can imagine, and the story escalates when the narrator starts a relationship with one of the other women on her team. Unrelated (or is it?): I took Twitter off my phone this month and I do not miss it!

Shadow and Bone — Netflix/Leigh Bardugo

I finally started a new knitting project (socks) and got to work with Season 2 of Shadow and Bone on in the background. Based on Leigh Bardugo’s Shadow and Bone book trilogy and her Six of Crows duology, it’s set in the fantastical Grishaverse where a select group of people with magical abilities (Grisha) must fight a lethal, encroaching darkness called The Fold. It was just the kind of escapism I was looking for: a fantasy world where everyone is attractive and there’s just enough real danger that the hero’s ultimate triumph feels earned. I enjoyed the Crows’ storyline much more than Alina’s (Ben Barnes as the Darkling being the one exception) and hope they get greenlit for all the ragtag heist spinoffs their hearts desire.

A Modern Mephistopheles — Louisa May Alcott

I found this strange little volume at the BPL’s winter book sale and did a double take because surely this was not the same Louisa May Alcott of Little Women fame?? Indeed it is! Apparently, after Alcott had made enough money writing her famous moral novels, she started experimenting with darker tales such as this “modern” take on Faust, featuring a young poet willing to give up his freedom for fame. Gothic, romantic, and a little campy, I can see how this never became a classic to the same level as Alcott’s more famous work, but fun nonetheless to see an author explore other parts of their talent.

The Quiet Girl

Phillip has been on a months-long campaign to get me to cry at a movie, and when he wasn’t expecting it, it finally happened!. The film is almost completely in Irish and is adapted from Claire Keegan’s story Foster, which I first read in a castle in Ireland (truly!). It’s the story of a young girl who goes to stay with older, childless relatives while her mother has a new baby. Under their care, the girl blossoms, oblivious to the heaviness of a tragic secret that still lingers in the house. I loved the gentleness of this movie, how it soothed with its soft, sunny tones and birdsong, evoking the feeling of contentment one feels coming home after a long day spent outside, knowing you’ll sleep soundly because you are loved.


The Foundation:

Book covers for Poems to Eat by Takuboku, American Estrangement by Said Sayrafiezadeh, and People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry

Poems to Eat — Takuboku

A dear old friend recommended these poems to me from the other side of the world (hi Nina!), so I was delighted to find that my library had an absolutely gorgeous copy on reserve, complete with stunning woodcut prints interspersed between the pages. Written in the traditional Japanese tanka style, these collected poems touch on everything from work and love to sickness, ennui, and a nostalgic longing for other lives. Considered one of the first modern Japanese poets, Takuboku completed most of his work in the early 1900s before dying of tuberculosis in 1912 at the age of 26. Sadly, this book is not available on Bookshop, so I’ll use this opportunity to again champion my favorite library app: Libby!

American Estrangement — Saïd Sayrafiezadeh

Some friends and I were thinking lately about who the greatest living/active short story writers of our time are, which made me realize how woefully not well-versed I am in modern short fiction. American Estrangement was one of my first steps toward remedying this predicament, and what I enjoyed most about the America of Sayrafiezadeh’s stories was that there was always something foreign about the mundane and something familiar in the strange. The stories range from speculative to introspective, exploring families, relationships, desires, and shames with humor and a fair, if sometimes harsh, sense of clarity. I read a lot of contemporary fiction, but this portrait of our country felt of the moment in a way that feels true and timely, and rare.

People We Meet on Vacation — Emily Henry

I’ve been saving Emily Henry for myself because I knew I’d love her and her books would feel like a treat for my tired brain. People We Meet on Vacation is a millennial spin on When Harry Met Sally, following two college best friends over a decade of sharing special summer trips and staunchly refusing to fall in love with each other—or at least admit it—for as long as possible. Poppy and Alex are charming, witty, colorful, and loveable people whose relationship you want to root for, but also, their mutual yearning is so addictive I wanted to stretch it out as long as possible. (It was Pisces season, okay? Give me a break.)


Solid Supports:

Book covers for Dyscalculia by Camonghne Felix and Happy All the Time by Laurie Colwin

Dyscalculia: A Love Story of Epic Miscalculation — Camonghne Felix

This was a beautifully short audiobook that I listened to over the course of a few lunch breaks, and which reaffirmed my love for listening to writers read their own work. A deeply personal memoir, Felix herself narrates the story of her childhood trauma and the ways in which that trauma shaped her mental chemistry and her ability to love and experience love. Using dyscalculia (the term for a math-specific learning disability) as a metaphor for her difficulties in processing and navigating the rest of her life, Felix’s story is vulnerable, raw, and exceptionally brave. She also has a gorgeous reading voice, which combined with her lyrical writing style turns her trauma into poetry, taking the pain of loving and living and transforming it into something devastatingly beautiful.

Happy All the Time — Laurie Colwin

This recommendation came from my adoptive literary godmother, Jami Attenberg, and her wonderful newsletter, Craft Talk. Jami described this book as “a perfect scoop of ice cream with some chocolate sauce served in a vintage sterling silver dessert bowl,” and honestly, I can’t really top that. Happy All the Time is about two men who are cousins and best friends who fall in love with two vastly different women in New York City. Published in 1978, the book evokes a bygone era of Manhattan that feels golden and hazy around the edges (although that’s probably just the cigarette smoke). The characters were quirky and strange but not in ways that we wouldn’t still recognize in ourselves today, and most importantly, they loved and cared for each other even when they didn’t fully understand each other. If this book is ice cream, then it should be a magic kind that melts only as quickly as you want it to and can last you a whole rainy weekend, as necessary.


THE TIPPY TOP:

Book cover for Homie by Danez Smith

Homie — Danez Smith

For a long time, I was really insecure about my ability to competently discuss poetry because I never formally studied it in school and I don’t read or write it as often as I do prose. Listening to Smith read their own poems during my first week commuting to my new job reminded me that the purpose of poetry is not to analyze, but to experience. Smith’s poems are positively bursting with life and love: love for life, love for their friends, and love in a world that makes loving difficult but so immensely worth doing anyway. They are in turns intimate and informal, funny and solemn, joyous, earnest, and as an exploration of Black queer identity, unabashedly proud. The poems are also deeply rooted in the loss of one of Smith’s best friends, whose presence and absence is a recurring theme throughout this collection.

As a straight white listener, I was very aware that these poems were not explicitly written for me, and that their reclamation of derogatory language and their proud refutation of shame as a Black queer person speaks to an experience and a power that will never be mine. For this reason, I especially recommend listening to these poems if you can, not only because Smith’s reading voice is truly a gift, but also because in being a listener, we silence our own internal monologues and cede the agency of our reading experience back to the speaker. Listening allows Smith the opportunity to invite us into their world on their own terms, in their own words, and to share their experiences in the most authentic way. As a collection, Homie is one big love letter to community, and to vicariously experience that community through Smith’s fierce love—even if only for a couple of hours—is a privilege.


And that was March! Thanks for reading, and thanks especially for your patience as I got everything set up with the new Bookshop stuff. I promise April’s recap will be on time.

In the meantime, feel free to let me know what you’re reading, what you’re thinking, what you’re loving. I’m always around to chat.

Until next time, happy reading!
❤ Catherine